Cucumber vs Ants: a Case Against the Myth of the Uses of Plant Extracts in Insect Pest Management

Authors

  • Matan Shelomi National Taiwan University http://orcid.org/0000-0003-4413-4097
  • Bo-Jun Qiu National Taiwan University
  • Lin-Ting Huang National Taiwan University

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.13102/sociobiology.v68i2.5813

Keywords:

olfaction, ants, Formicidae, repellency

Abstract

An accumulation of questionable scientific reports on the use of natural plant extracts to control household pest insects, using biologically irrelevant experimental designs and extremely high concentrations, has resulted in a publication bias: “promising” studies claiming readily available plants can repel various insects, including social insects, despite no usable data to judge cost-effectiveness or sustainability in a realistic situation. The Internet provides a further torrent of untested claims, generating a background noise of misinformation. An example is the belief that cucumbers are “natural” ant repellent, widely reported in such informal literature, despite no direct evidence for or against this claim. We tested this popular assertion using peel extracts of cucumber and the related bitter melon as olfactory and gustatory repellents against ants. Extracts of both fruit peels in water, methanol, or hexane were statistically significant but effectively weak gustatory repellents. Aqueous cucumber peel extract has a significant but mild olfactory repellent effect: about half of the ants were repelled relative to none in a control. While the myth may have a grain of truth to it, as cucumber does have a mild but detectable effect on ants in an artificial setup, its potential impact on keeping ants out of a treated perimeter would be extremely short-lived and not cost-effective. Superior ant management strategies are currently available. The promotion of “natural” products must be rooted in scientific evidence of a successful and cost-effective implementation prospect.

Author Biography

Matan Shelomi, National Taiwan University

Assistant Professor, Department of Entomology, National Taiwan University

References

Amer, A. & Mehlhorn, H. (2006). Repellency effect of forty-one essential oils against Aedes, Anopheles, and Culex mosquitoes. Parasitology Research, 99: 478. doi: 10.1007/s00436-006-0184-1

Carroll, S. P. & Loye, J. (2006). PMD, a Registered Botanical Mosquito Repellent with Deet-Like Efficacy. Journal of the American Mosquito Control Association, 22: 507-514, 508. doi: 10.2987/8756-971X(2006)22[507:PARBMR]2.0.CO;2

Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) (2019). CDC Yellow Book 2020: Health Information for International Travel. New York: Oxford University Press, 721p.

Clark, J. & Smith, R. (2015). Firm action needed on predatory journals. British Medical Journal, 350: h210. doi: 10.1136/bmj.h210

Francl, M. (2013). How to counteract chemophobia. Nature Chemistry, 5: 439-440. doi: 10.1038/nchem.1661

Gore, J. C. & Schal, C. (2004). Laboratory Evaluation of Boric Acid-Sugar Solutions as Baits for Management of German Cockroach Infestations. Journal of Economic Entomology, 97: 581-587. doi: 10.1093/jee/97.2.581

Johnson, S.B., Park, H.S., Gross, C.P. & Yu, J.B. (2017). Use of alternative medicine for cancer and its impact on survival. Journal of the National Cancer Institute, 110: 121-124. doi: 10.1093/jnci/djx145

Klotz, J., Greenberg, L. & Venn, E. C. (1998). Liquid Boric Acid Bait for Control of the Argentine Ant (Hymenoptera: Formicidae). Journal of Economic Entomology, 91: 910-914. doi: 10.1093/jee/91.4.910

Kurt, S. (2018). Why do authors publish in predatory journals? Learned Publishing ,31: 141-147. doi: 10.1002/leap.1150

Maugh, T.H. (1982). To attract or repel, that is the question. Science, 218: 278-278. doi: 10.1126/science.218.4569.278

Monte, P., Woodard, C., Ayer, R., Lilly, M., Sun, H. & Carlson, J. (1989). Characterization of the larval olfactory response in Drosophila and its genetic basis. Behavior Genetics, 19: 267-283. doi: 10.1007/BF01065910

Prasanna Kumar, K., Murugan, K., Kovendan, K., Naresh Kumar, A., Hwang, J.-S. & Barnard, D. R. (2012). Combined effect of seaweed (Sargassum wightii) and Bacillus thuringiensis var. israelensis on the coastal mosquito, Anopheles sundaicus, in Tamil Nadu, India. Science Asia, 38: 141-146. doi: 10.2306/scienceasia1513-1874.2012.38.141

Scriven, R. & Meloan, C.E. (1984). (E, Z)-2, 6-nonadien-1-al and (E)-2-nonen-1-al present in crushed cucumbers are natural repellents for the american cockroach (Periplaneta americana). The Ohio Journal of Science, 84: 82-85.

Shelomi, M. (2020). Who’s afraid of DEET? Fearmongering in papers on botanical repellents. Malaria Journal, 19: 1-3. doi: 10.1186/s12936-020-03217-5

Weigmann, K. (2018). The genesis of a conspiracy theory. EMBO Reports, 19: e45935. doi: 10.15252/embr.201845935

Wetterer, J.K. (2007). Biology and impacts of Pacific Islandinvasive species. 3. The African big-headed ant, Pheidole megacephala (Hym.: Formicidae). Pacific Science, 61: 437-456. doi: 10.2984/1 534-6188(2007)61[437:BAIOPI]2.0.CO;2

Zavrel, E. (2016). Pedagogical techniques employed by the television show “MythBusters”. The Physics Teacher, 54: 476-479. doi: 10.1119/1.4965268

Downloads

Published

2021-04-15

How to Cite

Shelomi, M., Qiu, B.-J., & Huang, L.-T. (2021). Cucumber vs Ants: a Case Against the Myth of the Uses of Plant Extracts in Insect Pest Management. Sociobiology, 68(2), e5813. https://doi.org/10.13102/sociobiology.v68i2.5813

Issue

Section

Opinion

Most read articles by the same author(s)